How to Meet Your Inner Critic – It Has a Story | Ep 02

Where did your inner critic come from? How can you meet your inner critic and really get to the bottom of its fear and judgment? What can you say to your inner critic to release shame, increase compassion, and free yourself from its fear of vulnerability? 

In this podcast episode, Emily Pagone discusses how to meet your inner critic.

Meet Emily Pagone

Emily Pagone is a licensed clinical professional counselor, trauma specialist, and the Owner & Clinical Director of Authentic Growth Wellness Group.

With over 15 years of experience supporting individuals, parents, families, and young adults through trauma, anxiety, parenthood, and grief, Emily combines deep clinical expertise with empathy and lived growth work.

She’s also a university lecturer and passionate advocate for destigmatizing mental health.

Connect with her on Instagram.

In This Podcast:

  • Let’s first normalize your inner critic 
  • Common inner critic origin stories
  • “I’m scared for you.”
  • Your activity for this week 

Let’s first normalize your inner critic 

The first thing I want you to hear today is this: every human has an inner critic. In IFS [internal family systems] … which recognizes that there are different emotional states that we have, [the] parts of us, this inner critic part is categorized as a manager part, which means it’s a protector. It has developed to keep you safe by anticipating danger or preventing shame.

Emily Pagone

From a neurobiological perspective, the inner critic is connected to the brain’s evolution-shaped negativity detection bias and the amygdala, which tries to predict threats based on past experiences. 

So, when your inner critic activates, it’s not because you’re failing. It’s because your nervous system is remembering.

Emily Pagone

Your inner critic responds to something in your environment. 

It is not a cue that something is wrong with you, but rather that something in your life or environment is similar enough to your past to trigger an old memory, trauma, or wound, causing you to preemptively react, pull away, or assume the worst.  

Common inner critic origin stories

Some of the common origins of inner critics may include the following: 

  • Childhood attachment trauma. 

Attachment research … shows that children internalize feedback from caregivers to maintain safety, and connection with them – even if they don’t make them feel good. If love or approval felt inconsistent or conditional, the critic learned, “If I monitor myself, I’ll stay connected. If I perform well, I’ll be okay.” The inner critic becomes an internalized attachment strategy.

Emily Pagone
  • Trauma in the survival brain. 
  • Social and cultural conditioning, this includes high-achieving school structures, gender norms, immigrant family expectations, and others. 
  • Inner critics can form from neurodivergence and masking demands in a society that is not attuned or open to neurodiversity 

“I’m scared for you.”

Often, we can take what the inner critic says to us and look beneath the surface of its accusations and judgments to see what it really is trying to tell us: “I am scared for you.” 

That is really the crux of what the inner critic is trying to do when it pleads with us to avoid vulnerability. 

Right now, if you are in a safe place to do this, check in with yourself, and ask these questions:

  • Where does your inner critic come up the most? 
  • What does it sound like? 
  • Whose voice does the inner critic speak through? 
  • What age is the voice of the speaker? 

As you connect with this part, feel it, and get a good felt sense of it, ask it or send it this question: “What does it believe it’s protecting you from?” See what message it gives you back.

Emily Pagone

The importance of discovering more about your inner critic’s origin is that the shame decreases, and compassion shows up. 

Your activity for this week

Write a letter from your inner critic to you. Embody your inner critic energy, invite it to come to the forefront of your mind, and express its fears, purpose, and memories to you in the form of a letter. 

Then, write a letter from your wise self – the energetic opposite of the inner critic. Respond to the inner critic from your wise self, your inner self – and if you feel like you cannot access that wise part of you, imagine what they could be like. 

This is a bilateral exercise that can bring you more clarity and compassion for yourself and help you move forward. 

RESOURCES MENTIONED AND USEFUL LINKS

Practice of the Practice Network

Rate, review, and subscribe to this podcast on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, Google Podcasts, TuneIn, Audible/Amazon, and Spotify.

CONNECT WITH ME

Check out my Instagram

ABOUT THE INNER CRITIC PODCAST

The Inner Critic, is a heart-centered, healing-forward audio space where listeners learn to understand, befriend, and transform the internal voices that hold them back.

Rather than silencing the inner critic, Emily explores where it came from, what it’s been trying to protect us from, and how we can cultivate compassion and self-acceptance in its presence.

The show gently guides neurodivergent adults, parents, and anyone navigating self-doubt toward greater clarity, resilience, and peace with themselves.

More Episodes

Finding, Befriending, and the Power of Taking your Inner Critic on Walks with Kat Torninger | Ep 06

Leadership, Boundaries, and Burnout | Ep 05

Befriending Inner Critics in Neurodivergent Nervous Systems with Allie Casazza | Ep 05

The Voice That Pushes: Learning When to Slow Down with Joe Sanok | Ep 03

How to Meet Your Inner Critic – It Has a Story | Ep 02

The Voice That Tries to Protect You (But Keeps You Stuck) | Ep 01